Hotels in Shelter Island

Search Shelter Island Hotels

Get Secret Prices on selected hotels

These prices aren’t available to everyone.

Pay now or later on most rooms

Free cancellation on most rooms

Price Guarantee

Best Shelter Island Hotels

Hotels.com currently has 10 hotels in Shelter Island!

Our 5 most booked Shelter Island hotels from the last hour are:

1. Fordham House
2. SEVEN - Shelter Island Guest House
3. The Chequit Inn
4. Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast
5. Shelter Island House


But, low prices and a great selection are not the only thing Hotels.com offers. We also have 0 genuine Hotels.com guest reviews for Shelter Island.

Why use Hotels.com to book your Shelter Island accommodation?

We can help you to find the perfect Shelter Island hotel room for almost any occasion. With our fast and secure hotel search you may compare different Shelter Island hotels by:

  • - Price
  • - Availability
  • - Shelter Island neighbourhoods
  • - Nearby Shelter Island attractions and landmarks
  • - 0 genuine Hotels.com guest reviews for Shelter Island
  • - Star rating
  • - Amenities
  • - Hotel name & chain
  • - Theme


Alternatively, you can use our detailed Shelter Island maps showing hotel locations in Shelter Island, using all the filters listed above.

Cheap Shelter Island hotels - getting the best deal

On Hotels.com you can always be sure you're getting the best deal.

We make it easy to save money on every booking. We offer our Price Guarantee on most bookings. Plus we offer 3 more ways to save:

1. Hotels.com Rewards - Collect 10 nights, get 1 free*
2. Hotels.com Deals - Search over 10,000 deals!
3. Hotels.com voucher codes - All our official promo and discount codes in one place.